Skip to main content

Reviews FAQs

Answers to the most common questions about reviews in Dapple — Review Rounds, assigning reviewers, automatic sending and Share them out, scoring, deadlines and what reviewers see.

Written by Oz Osbaldeston

What is a review in Dapple?

Reviews in Dapple are how submissions get assessed before you make a decision. Each in-progress stage can have a Review Round, which holds the guidance, deadlines and scoring for that review. You assign reviewers to submissions yourself from the submissions list or the Stages board, or turn on automatic sending so every submission that reaches the stage goes to a reviewer pool. These are the questions we're asked most often. For the full picture, start with What Are Reviews in Dapple?.

What is a Review Round?

A Review Round is the review setup attached to an in-progress stage. It holds the round's name, guidance, deadlines, scoring and notifications, and whether submissions are sent to reviewers automatically. A project can have several Review Rounds, each configured separately from Workflow & Reviews. See How to Create a Review Round in Dapple.

Do I need a separate stage or Review Round for each reviewer?

No. You assign reviewers to individual submissions, so one Review Round can have different reviewers on different submissions. To split a large volume evenly, use Share them out instead.

What is a reviewer pool?

A reviewer pool is the list of reviewers a Review Round sends submissions to automatically. It only exists when Send automatically when a submission reaches this stage is on. With it off, there's no pool and you assign reviewers yourself.

Should I turn on automatic sending?

Most rounds leave it off. Turn it on when submissions arrive over time and reviewers should get them straight away, such as a rolling open call. Leave it off for awards and prizes where entries are allocated after closing, or whenever you want to choose who reviews what.

What does Share them out do?

Share them out spreads submissions evenly across the reviewer pool, balancing the workload. You set how many reviewers each submission goes to. With 100 submissions and 5 reviewers, setting it to 1 gives each reviewer 20. Setting it to 2 means every submission is reviewed twice, so each reviewer gets 40.

What's the difference between Chosen reviewers and Share them out?

Chosen reviewers

Share them out

Every submission goes to everyone in the pool

Each submission goes to a set number of reviewers from the pool

Best for small panels where everyone reviews everything

Best for large volumes where the work needs splitting

Assigning reviewers

How do I assign a reviewer to a submission?

Assign reviewers to one submission or many from the submissions list, or from the Stages board. Choose the Review Round and the reviewers. See How to Send Submissions for Review in Dapple.

Does a submission need to be in the right stage before I assign a reviewer?

No. When you assign a reviewer to a Review Round, Dapple moves the submission into that round's stage automatically.

Can I assign reviewers before they've accepted their invite?

Yes. Reviewers show as pending until they accept, but you can assign them submissions straight away. Everything assigned in the meantime is waiting in their Review Account when they accept.

Who can review submissions?

Anyone in your organisation who's assigned a submission. External judges should be invited with the Reviewer permission only, so they can't see your admin dashboard. See How to Add a User.

Can an admin or team member also be a reviewer?

Yes. Admins and team members already have a Review Account, so there's no need to invite them again. Assign them submissions like any other reviewer. They find their reviews by opening the side panel on the right and selecting My Reviews.

Can several reviewers review the same submission?

Yes. Assign as many reviewers as you need, or use Share them out to send each submission to a set number. Each reviewer's feedback is saved separately, and reviewers can't see each other's scores.

Reviewing submissions

What do Awaiting Review, In Review and Submitted mean?

Queue

What it means

Awaiting Review

Assigned to the reviewer but not started yet

In Review

Started, with feedback saved as a draft

Submitted

Finished and sent back to the admin team

Can I save a review and come back later?

Yes. Saved reviews stay under In Review until you submit them.

Can I edit a review after submitting it?

Not yourself — submitted reviews are final. An admin can reopen your review so you can change it and resubmit. See How to Reverse a Submitted Review So a Reviewer Can Edit It Again.

Can I review on a phone or tablet?

Yes, in any modern browser. A larger screen makes reading files and scoring easier.

What is blind review?

Blind review hides identifying fields — such as an applicant's name, email or address — from reviewers to reduce bias. See How to Create Blind Submissions.

Why can't I see a submission I expected to review?

Usually because it hasn't been assigned to you yet. Check with the programme admin. If you're an admin or team member, look under My Reviews in the side panel on the right.

Scoring, deadlines and progress

How are scores worked out?

Each reviewer scores on the scale you set. Dapple shows every score out of 100 so they can be compared. With Rubric scoring, each criterion is converted and weighted to give one total. See Why Are Review Scores Always Shown Out of 100 in Dapple?.

How do I make sure every submission gets enough reviews?

Set a minimum number of reviews on the Review Round's Deadlines step. If you use Share them out, send each submission to at least that many reviewers. See How to Set Review Round Thresholds in Dapple.

Can I set a deadline for reviewers?

Yes — a specific date, or a number of days from when each submission reaches a reviewer. Reviewers can still submit after it passes. See How to Set a Due Date for Reviewers.

How do I track review progress?

Use the Review Round's Stats section, the Reviewers section in the left-hand navigation, or the Assigned Reviewers column in the submissions list. See How do I view and manage all my reviewers in Dapple?.

Why can't I move a submission to another stage?

Submissions with open reviews stay in their stage until their reviews are marked complete — shown by a blue dot. Mark them complete once you have enough feedback. See How to Mark Reviews as Complete.

What happens when all reviews are complete?

The submission is ready to move on. Compare scores, votes and comments, then move it to the next stage or reject it. Review data is kept for reporting.

Where to go next

Did this answer your question?